Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Liquor Laws: Right of Passage?

New statutes may result in consumer casualties



 



With the passage of SB 383 and SJR 68 in May, Oklahomans will be voting for large-scale changes to our alcoholic beverage laws in November. Rather than approach the reformation of our liquor laws conservatively, state legislators – notably Sens. Stephanie Bice and Clark Jolley – pushed to completely rewrite Article 28 of the state constitution, as well as Title 37 of the Oklahoma statutes. It’s essentially a total overhaul of how our state deals with alcohol, the main focus of which has been allowing the sale and purchase of strong beer (higher than 4 percent ABV) and wine of less than 15 percent ABV in retail locations such as grocery and convenience stores.
 

According to Bryan Kerr, president of the Retail Liquor Association of Oklahoma, SJR 68 repeals and replaces Article 28, and SB 383 replaces the language of Title 37, legislation that covers all Oklahoma statutes related to alcohol (beer, wine and liquor). In November, voters will decide on a state question to replace Article 28 with Article 28A, legislation that includes all the proposed verbiage from SB 383. If it passes – and SB 383 has already been approved by the Legislature and signed by the governor – some provisions will go into effect in 2017, but most will be delayed until October 2018.

Retailers and brokers (agents of the manufacturers) and some wholesalers in the state have raised strong objections to the legislation, but Bice (R-Oklahoma City) and Jolley (R-Edmond) have not responded to multiple requests for clarification of the bill’s verbiage. Matt Sterr, managing partner of Spirit Shop in Norman, called SB 383 a “wholesale change to the system to benefit out-of-state interests.”

Sterr said the legislation has been sold to consumers as a slate of new conveniences, but those conveniences are not without substantial consequences, most of which the retailers believe are bad for consumers.

When a piece of legislation is sold using words that are difficult to define or the definition of which is questionable (e.g., convenience, or modern versus archaic laws), it is worth looking at what is actually being sold. Convenience is a good thing, but liquor retailers insist there are multiple costs to these new conveniences, including a reduction in selection, a rise in prices, a loss of small businesses and a system that will be incredibly difficult to regulate. If local beer and boutique wines don’t end up in large retailers – and it is unlikely they will if the legislation passes – then consumers will be driving across town to one or two niche stores that carry their favorites.

Some of this is due to the tendency of retailers to maximize shelf space, meaning only high-volume products would be stocked – ones that cost less and have high name recognition, which is not to say the best available choices. Additionally, pricing is sure to go up at the wholesale level, as the current system guarantees that Oklahoma prices on a product offered by the distributors (wholesalers) can be no higher than the lowest price offered in the six surrounding states, and, according to Kerr, “the current wholesale model allows for unfettered competition among many different Oklahoma-owned wholesalers.”

“The legislation would create a franchising system much like Texas has,” Sterr says. “Their costs are 25-40 percent higher than ours.”

Modern here, it seems, means more expensive. Confusion arises when people drive to Texas and see their favorite bottle of liquor priced cheaper than it is in Oklahoma, but that is a function of the franchising system and usually only applies to a small number of offerings – special discounts to retailers on certain “loss-leader” items, much like Walmart operates. Under current Oklahoma law, those sorts of arrangements are illegal. All alcohol products coming into the state must be offered by all distributors at the same price.

While Sterr calls the franchising system the most egregious change to the laws – it would allow for price controls and gouging, for example – Kerr also points to the inequity in the way wine and strong beer will be handled in stores such as Walmart or Target if the legislation passes.

“A retailer in Oklahoma may now have one license to sell liquor, wine and beer, and a married couple may have two,” Kerr says, “but SJR 68 and SB 383 would give unlimited wine and beer licenses to large retailers like Walmart and 7-Eleven while maintaining that Oklahoma citizens would still only get one license per person.”

This is one of the provisions of the proposed law that has come under fire from opponents because it is fundamentally unjust. The extension of multiple licenses will lead to an expansion of wine and beer in retail locations, from the current 658 licensed establishments to more than 4,000 potential licensed establishments. This leads to Kerr’s strongest warning about the new legislation.



… Why are we going to send hundreds of millions in revenue out of state
to Walmart, Target and Costco?


- Matt Sterr
 


“How much more access will minors have once strong beer and wine are in more than 4,000 locations?” he asked. “In fact, there is nothing in the legislation to prevent 16-year-olds from handling alcohol at large retail locations. The legislation also reduces the age at which someone can sell stronger alcohol from 21 to 18. Is it really good public policy to increase underage access to stronger alcohol just to save grocery and convenience stores a few extra bucks in their hiring and training practices?” (This is one of the questions that proponents had not answered as of press time.)

Sterr has a timely and pragmatic question, too. “At a time when we are facing a $1 billion budget shortfall, why are we going to send hundreds of millions in revenue out of state to Walmart, Target and Costco?”

In addition to the revenues lost to out-of-state interests, there is also the question of impact on local businesses. Kerr said he expects that many mom-and-pop stores would have to close. High-volume bottles keep some of the smaller stores in business, but those high-volume bottles would be the ones that large retailers stock the most.

Alex Kroblin is the managing partner of Thirst Wine Merchants, a brokerage in Oklahoma. The brokerage tier is the most endangered as a whole in the proposed legislation. “We would essentially have to convert to a wholesaler,” Kroblin says. “That would mean expenditures on trucks, drivers, et cetera, or we would also have to sell our goods to whatever wholesalers would still be around.”

This is one of the more complex problems with the proposed system. The state’s two largest wholesalers – Central and Jarboe – would be able to create exclusive agreements with large brokerages; the state’s two largest are Republic National Distributing and Glazers (owned by Southern Wine & Spirits). According to SJR 68, those brokers would then be able to buy controlling interest in these same wholesalers, essentially designating themselves as the sole distributors of their family of products, representing more than 80 percent of the wine and spirits sold in our state. This is the heart of franchising.

According to Kerr, manufacturers would control their products’ distribution and pricing via exclusive agreements with and ownership in large wholesalers, thereby creating a veritable monopoly on specific brands – ironic given that proponents of SJR 68 and SB 338 accused the current licensed retail stores and distributors of having a monopoly under current legislation. In fact, the current system is rigged for competitiveness, as all entities have access to all products at the same prices from the brokers, and then have to compete at both the wholesale and retail level to offer the best prices to the consumer.

Are some elements of these proposed new laws beneficial to consumers? Certainly. Is the gain in convenience free from side effects as a result? Unfortunately not – and time, and the ballot box, will tell how strong a hit might be in store for all elements of the industry, including the customers. 


► The Tab for New Legislation

• Open, competitive wholesale system with seven different distribution companies all vying for business.

• Selection driven by local consumer demand.

• Prices held down by competition at every level.

• Limited underage access to strong alcohol due to

• local ownership, restricted hours of operation and severe penalties.

• Liquor, wine and strong beer served by 18+ and sold by 21+.

• Fewer than 700 retail licenses.

• Restricted access for minors (not allowed in bars, liquor stores).

• Sales revenue primarily benefits local owners and state of Oklahoma.

• One license per person and two for a married couple.

 

• Closed, franchise system with up to 90 percent of the market controlled by two distribution companies.

• Selection dictated by two wholesalers/distributors.

• Price increases due to lack of competition and additional cost of delivering to thousands of new outlets.

• Increased underage access to strong alcohol due to corporate ownership, extended hours and lighter penalties.

• Liquor, wine and beer sold by 18+ and stocked by 16+.

• More than 4,000 retail licenses, including convenience stores.

• Unrestricted access for minors in Walmart, Target, 7-Eleven, etc.

• Sales revenue primarily benefits out-of-state companies.

• One license per person, two for a married couple, and unlimited licenses for large retailers (Walmart, Target, 7-Eleven, etc.).

 

Edit ModuleShow Tags

Archive »You Might Like

What's Up in the 405

Our top 6 picks for fun stuff to do in and around OKC

New Year’s Getaways for 2019

If you’re heading out of the 405 to mark the end of 2018, here are a couple of getaways to make New Year’s Eve a memorable one.

Opening Night Rings in 2019

Head downtown to ring in the new year with thousands upon thousands of friends – it’s almost time for Arts Council OKC’s Opening Night.

Add your comment:
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Calendar

December 2018

Visitors to Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary will be able to let their imaginations run wild as they travel back in time with life-size animatronic dinosaurs along a half-mile...

Where:
Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
1 Nature Place
McKinney, TX  75069
View map »


Sponsor: Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
Telephone: 972.562.5566
Contact Name: Stephanie Jennings
Website »

More information

A pop-up shop village & Christmas tree lot in Midtown, OKC for the Holiday season. Shops rotate weekly!

Cost: Free

Where:
Holiday Pop-Up Shops
399 NW 10th St
Oklahoma City, OK  73102
View map »


Telephone: 405.514.5205
Contact Name: Cleo Rajon
Website »

More information

Don’t miss this timely exhibition charting the development of contemporary Indigenous art from the US and Canada. Presenting over 80 artworks including paintings, photography, video,...

Cost: Free

Where:
Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art
600 Museum Way
Bentonville, AR  72712
View map »


Telephone: 479.418.5700
Website »

More information

The National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum is proud to host an exhibition by members of the Traditional Cowboy Arts Association (TCAA).   The Traditional Cowboy Arts Association...

Cost: 12.50

Where:
National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum
1700 Northeast 63rd Street
Oklahoma City, OK  73111
View map »


Telephone: 405.478.2250
Contact Name: Jenni Shrum
Website »

More information

Grab your family and friends for an incredible performance and reimagining of the classic holiday story! Follow Carlos on his hip hop journey to self-discovery through magical lands filled with...

Cost: $20 presale; $25 at the door

Where:
OCCC
7777 S May
Oklahoma City, OK  73159
View map »


Sponsor: RACE Dance Company
Telephone: 405.410.4978
Contact Name: Hui Poos
Website »

More information

Grab your family and friends for an incredible performance and reimagining of the classic holiday story! Follow Carlos on his hip hop journey to self-discovery through magical lands filled with...

Cost: $20 presale; $25 at the door

Where:
OCCC
7777 S May
Oklahoma City, OK  73159
View map »


Sponsor: RACE Dance Company
Telephone: 405.410.4978
Contact Name: Hui Poos
Website »

More information

Elsa and Anna host this holiday spectacular full of Christmas magic - with a drop-in visit from the big man himself: Santa Claus! Featuring high-quality professional performers from Project...

Cost: $35

Where:
The Station at Central Park
700 S Broadway Avenue
Moore , OK  73160
View map »


Sponsor: Project Princess
Telephone: 405.777.2411
Contact Name: Brooke Ashely
Website »

More information

You’re invited to hear Sandi Patty in a free concert for the whole family in the Crossings OKC Sanctuary. Sandi, her family and the Voices of Crossings Choir and Orchestra will share the...

Cost: Free

Where:
Crossings Community Church - OKC Campus
14600 North Portland
Oklahoma City, OK  73134
View map »


Sponsor: Crossings Community Church
Telephone: 405.302.1258
Contact Name: Lori Bunyar
Website »

More information

The American Spirit Dance Company Presents Home for the Holidays Thursday, December 6, 8:00 PM, Kirkpatrick Theatre Friday, December 7, 8:00 PM, Kirkpatrick Theatre Saturday, December 8,...

Cost: $18.85 - $29.85

Where:
Oklahoma City University
2501 N. Blackwelder
Oklahoma City, OK  73106
View map »


Sponsor: The American Spirit Dance Company
Telephone: 405.208.4955
Contact Name: Ryan Barrett
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...

The National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum is proud to host an exhibition by members of the Traditional Cowboy Arts Association (TCAA).   The Traditional Cowboy Arts Association...

Cost: 12.50

Where:
National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum
1700 Northeast 63rd Street
Oklahoma City, OK  73111
View map »


Telephone: 405.478.2250
Contact Name: Jenni Shrum
Website »

More information

Don’t miss this timely exhibition charting the development of contemporary Indigenous art from the US and Canada. Presenting over 80 artworks including paintings, photography, video,...

Cost: Free

Where:
Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art
600 Museum Way
Bentonville, AR  72712
View map »


Telephone: 479.418.5700
Website »

More information

Upcoming Casting Calls in Oklahoma City Location: Provided via email Send headshots, measurements, resume and preferred audition time to casting@princessparty.com We are seeking actors who...

Cost: Free

Where:
Provided via email
Provided via email
Oklahoma City, OK  73112
View map »


Sponsor: The Princess Party Co.
Telephone: 616.426.6108
Contact Name: Skyler
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...

Visitors to Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary will be able to let their imaginations run wild as they travel back in time with life-size animatronic dinosaurs along a half-mile...

Where:
Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
1 Nature Place
McKinney, TX  75069
View map »


Sponsor: Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
Telephone: 972.562.5566
Contact Name: Stephanie Jennings
Website »

More information

Don’t miss this timely exhibition charting the development of contemporary Indigenous art from the US and Canada. Presenting over 80 artworks including paintings, photography, video,...

Cost: Free

Where:
Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art
600 Museum Way
Bentonville, AR  72712
View map »


Telephone: 479.418.5700
Website »

More information

The National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum is proud to host an exhibition by members of the Traditional Cowboy Arts Association (TCAA).   The Traditional Cowboy Arts Association...

Cost: 12.50

Where:
National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum
1700 Northeast 63rd Street
Oklahoma City, OK  73111
View map »


Telephone: 405.478.2250
Contact Name: Jenni Shrum
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...

Visitors to Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary will be able to let their imaginations run wild as they travel back in time with life-size animatronic dinosaurs along a half-mile...

Where:
Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
1 Nature Place
McKinney, TX  75069
View map »


Sponsor: Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
Telephone: 972.562.5566
Contact Name: Stephanie Jennings
Website »

More information

Don’t miss this timely exhibition charting the development of contemporary Indigenous art from the US and Canada. Presenting over 80 artworks including paintings, photography, video,...

Cost: Free

Where:
Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art
600 Museum Way
Bentonville, AR  72712
View map »


Telephone: 479.418.5700
Website »

More information

The National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum is proud to host an exhibition by members of the Traditional Cowboy Arts Association (TCAA).   The Traditional Cowboy Arts Association...

Cost: 12.50

Where:
National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum
1700 Northeast 63rd Street
Oklahoma City, OK  73111
View map »


Telephone: 405.478.2250
Contact Name: Jenni Shrum
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...

Visitors to Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary will be able to let their imaginations run wild as they travel back in time with life-size animatronic dinosaurs along a half-mile...

Where:
Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
1 Nature Place
McKinney, TX  75069
View map »


Sponsor: Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
Telephone: 972.562.5566
Contact Name: Stephanie Jennings
Website »

More information

The National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum is proud to host an exhibition by members of the Traditional Cowboy Arts Association (TCAA).   The Traditional Cowboy Arts Association...

Cost: 12.50

Where:
National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum
1700 Northeast 63rd Street
Oklahoma City, OK  73111
View map »


Telephone: 405.478.2250
Contact Name: Jenni Shrum
Website »

More information

Don’t miss this timely exhibition charting the development of contemporary Indigenous art from the US and Canada. Presenting over 80 artworks including paintings, photography, video,...

Cost: Free

Where:
Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art
600 Museum Way
Bentonville, AR  72712
View map »


Telephone: 479.418.5700
Website »

More information

A pop-up shop village & Christmas tree lot in Midtown, OKC for the Holiday season. Shops rotate weekly!

Cost: Free

Where:
Holiday Pop-Up Shops
399 NW 10th St
Oklahoma City, OK  73102
View map »


Telephone: 405.514.5205
Contact Name: Cleo Rajon
Website »

More information

A Comedy by Michael Hollinger No menu necessary at the world's greatest restaurant, the Café du Grand Boeuf in Paris. Why? "Because we have everything," headwaiter...

Cost: $5 to $25

Where:
Carpenter Square Theatre
800 W. Main
Oklahoma City, OK  73106
View map »


Sponsor: Carpenter Square Theatre
Telephone: 405.232.6500
Contact Name: Rhonda M. Clark
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...

Visitors to Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary will be able to let their imaginations run wild as they travel back in time with life-size animatronic dinosaurs along a half-mile...

Where:
Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
1 Nature Place
McKinney, TX  75069
View map »


Sponsor: Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
Telephone: 972.562.5566
Contact Name: Stephanie Jennings
Website »

More information

A pop-up shop village & Christmas tree lot in Midtown, OKC for the Holiday season. Shops rotate weekly!

Cost: Free

Where:
Holiday Pop-Up Shops
399 NW 10th St
Oklahoma City, OK  73102
View map »


Telephone: 405.514.5205
Contact Name: Cleo Rajon
Website »

More information

The National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum is proud to host an exhibition by members of the Traditional Cowboy Arts Association (TCAA).   The Traditional Cowboy Arts Association...

Cost: 12.50

Where:
National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum
1700 Northeast 63rd Street
Oklahoma City, OK  73111
View map »


Telephone: 405.478.2250
Contact Name: Jenni Shrum
Website »

More information

Don’t miss this timely exhibition charting the development of contemporary Indigenous art from the US and Canada. Presenting over 80 artworks including paintings, photography, video,...

Cost: Free

Where:
Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art
600 Museum Way
Bentonville, AR  72712
View map »


Telephone: 479.418.5700
Website »

More information

Andy Alligator's is hosting a parents night out: Kids will enjoy supervised fun, food and games while parents have a night out on the town to finish up last-minute shopping without the kids....

Cost: $19.95

Where:
Andy Alligator's Fun Park
3300 Market Place Dr
Norman, OK  73072
View map »


Telephone: 405.321.7275
Website »

More information

Come enjoy live, local comedy in Oklahoma City's Plaza District. Shows are Fridays and Saturdays at 7:30 and 9:30 p.m., and the 2nd Saturday of every month also has a family -friendly show...

Cost: $5 - $15

Where:
OKC Improv
1757 N.W. 16th St.
Oklahoma City, OK  73106
View map »


Sponsor: OKC Improv
Telephone: 405.456.9858
Contact Name: Kate McLain-Snipes
Website »

More information

With the original Die Hard quickly becoming one of the most popular Christmas films around, we knew that everybody around town would be showing it. So we figured you know what's better than Die...

Cost: $7.50 - $9.50

Where:
Rodeo Cinema
2221 Exchange Ave
Oklahoma City, OK  73108
View map »


Sponsor: VHSANDCHILL
Telephone: 405.503.0050
Contact Name: Sean Peel
Website »

More information

A Comedy by Michael Hollinger No menu necessary at the world's greatest restaurant, the Café du Grand Boeuf in Paris. Why? "Because we have everything," headwaiter...

Cost: $5 to $25

Where:
Carpenter Square Theatre
800 W. Main
Oklahoma City, OK  73106
View map »


Sponsor: Carpenter Square Theatre
Telephone: 405.232.6500
Contact Name: Rhonda M. Clark
Website »

More information

Presented By OKC Ballet, with the OKC Philharmonic Tchaikovsky’s familiar score and Artistic Director Robert Mills’ delightful staging of The Nutcracker will fill your heart...

Where:
Civic Center Music Hall-Thelma Gaylord Theater
201 N Walker
Oklahoma City, OK  73102
View map »


Sponsor: OKC Ballet
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...

Visitors to Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary will be able to let their imaginations run wild as they travel back in time with life-size animatronic dinosaurs along a half-mile...

Where:
Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
1 Nature Place
McKinney, TX  75069
View map »


Sponsor: Heard Natural Science Museum & Wildlife Sanctuary
Telephone: 972.562.5566
Contact Name: Stephanie Jennings
Website »

More information

Don’t miss this timely exhibition charting the development of contemporary Indigenous art from the US and Canada. Presenting over 80 artworks including paintings, photography, video,...

Cost: Free

Where:
Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art
600 Museum Way
Bentonville, AR  72712
View map »


Telephone: 479.418.5700
Website »

More information

A pop-up shop village & Christmas tree lot in Midtown, OKC for the Holiday season. Shops rotate weekly!

Cost: Free

Where:
Holiday Pop-Up Shops
399 NW 10th St
Oklahoma City, OK  73102
View map »


Telephone: 405.514.5205
Contact Name: Cleo Rajon
Website »

More information

The National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum is proud to host an exhibition by members of the Traditional Cowboy Arts Association (TCAA).   The Traditional Cowboy Arts Association...

Cost: 12.50

Where:
National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum
1700 Northeast 63rd Street
Oklahoma City, OK  73111
View map »


Telephone: 405.478.2250
Contact Name: Jenni Shrum
Website »

More information

Come enjoy live, local comedy in Oklahoma City's Plaza District. Shows are Fridays and Saturdays at 7:30 and 9:30 p.m., and the 2nd Saturday of every month also has a family -friendly show...

Cost: $5 - $15

Where:
OKC Improv
1757 N.W. 16th St.
Oklahoma City, OK  73106
View map »


Sponsor: OKC Improv
Telephone: 405.456.9858
Contact Name: Kate McLain-Snipes
Website »

More information

With the original Die Hard quickly becoming one of the most popular Christmas films around, we knew that everybody around town would be showing it. So we figured you know what's better than Die...

Cost: $7.50 - $9.50

Where:
Rodeo Cinema
2221 Exchange Ave
Oklahoma City, OK  73108
View map »


Sponsor: VHSANDCHILL
Telephone: 405.503.0050
Contact Name: Sean Peel
Website »

More information

Presented By OKC Ballet, with the OKC Philharmonic Tchaikovsky’s familiar score and Artistic Director Robert Mills’ delightful staging of The Nutcracker will fill your heart...

Where:
Civic Center Music Hall-Thelma Gaylord Theater
201 N Walker
Oklahoma City, OK  73102
View map »


Sponsor: OKC Ballet
Website »

More information

A Comedy by Michael Hollinger No menu necessary at the world's greatest restaurant, the Café du Grand Boeuf in Paris. Why? "Because we have everything," headwaiter...

Cost: $5 to $25

Where:
Carpenter Square Theatre
800 W. Main
Oklahoma City, OK  73106
View map »


Sponsor: Carpenter Square Theatre
Telephone: 405.232.6500
Contact Name: Rhonda M. Clark
Website »

More information

Show More...
Show Less...
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module Edit ModuleShow Tags